controversial gene drive research sparking ethical debate
Last Updated : GMT 09:40:38
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Last Updated : GMT 09:40:38
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

To carry disease are pushing ahead

Controversial 'gene drive' research sparking ethical debate

Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicleControversial 'gene drive' research sparking ethical debate

The Oxitec mosquito developed by Intrexon is not technically a gene drive
Honolulu - Arab Today

Scientific techniques that can wipe out invasive species or alter mosquitoes' ability to carry disease are pushing ahead, raising concerns about the ethics of permanently changing the natural world, experts say.

This fast-moving field of science -- which involves changing the biology of creatures by interfering with their DNA -- is increasingly being debated not only for human health purposes, but also in conservation circles. 

Perhaps the most controversial type of research is known as a "gene drive," which ensures that a certain trait is passed down from parent to offspring. It eventually leads to genetic changes throughout the entire species.

Projects being considered include one to release altered mice on islands that will only bear male offspring, ensuring an end to future generations, scientists said at the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) World Conservation Congress.

Another idea is to save endangered birds on the Hawaiian islands by releasing altered mosquitoes that cannot carry avian malaria.

The Oxitec mosquito developed by Intrexon is not technically a "gene drive," but cuts down on the population of mosquitoes by introducing altered males whose offspring cannot survive.

Proponents of gene drive technology say it eliminates the need for polluting pesticides, and could offer a more effective remedy against invasive species than any tool on hand.

But opponents fear the impacts of permanently altering life forms on Earth and its unknown  -- and likely irreversible -- impact on creatures and ecosystems.

- 'Behind closed doors' -

Kevin Esvelt, an assistant professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), is among the first scientists to propose using gene-editing, or CRISPR technology, to alter species.

He is also one of the most cautious voices on its potential uses.

"As a scientist who worked on it, I am particularly concerned because we scientists are ultimately morally responsible for all the consequences of our work," Esvelt said at a panel discussion at the IUCN meeting in Honolulu.

"It should be a requirement that no one gets to build a gene drive or any technology designed to alter the shared environment in a laboratory without making their proposals public first," he said.

"If something goes wrong in the laboratory, it can affect people outside the laboratory," Esvelt added.

"That means if you do it behind closed doors -- as is traditional in science -- then you are not giving people a voice in a decision that might affect them."

He also said the current regulatory environment is "all based around release. And not really stringent enough, frankly, if you ask me."

 Quick action -

But others at the same panel called for quick action to preserve imperiled species before they disappear forever due to invasive species and diseases.

"One of the scariest things of working in conservation in Hawaii is there is no way to save these birds from malaria," said Chris Farmer, Hawaii program director of the American Bird Conservancy.

A total of 38 forest birds in Hawaii have gone extinct already due in large part to avian diseases, and 21 of the remaining 32 species are at risk, experts say.

By not exploring new technologies, "we are choosing to let these species go extinct," Farmer said.

Another speaker on the panel, Anthony James, professor of microbiology and molecular genetics at the University of California Irvine School of Medicine, said time is of the essence.

"You have heard the urgency in the voices of my colleagues here worried about the birds and the trees," he said.

"One of the key things that is going to be important for this technology is the ability to get these genes out in a very rapid way in the population."

- Call for caution -

According to Floyd Reed, a scientist at the University of Hawaii who is working on a project to alter Culex mosquitoes which transmit avian malaria to birds, gene drive technologies are incredibly diverse.

Some could theoretically spread from a single small release and genetically transform an entire species, he told AFP via email.

"These should be treated extremely cautiously. And there are other types of population modification genetic technology that are safer, geographically self limiting, and reversible."

At the ongoing IUCN World Conservation Congress, a meeting of environmentalists and heads of state from around the world that runs from September 1-10 and has drawn some 9,000 heads of state and environmentalists to Hawaii, members adopted a motion to refrain "from supporting or endorsing research, including field trials, into the use of gene drives for conservation or other purposes" until a rapid assessment is completed by 2020.

However, the motion is non-binding, and does not prevent anyone from pursuing research.

British primatologist Jane Goodall and dozens of other environmentalists and scientists have signed an open letter expressing concern about the use of gene drives in military, agriculture and conservation.

The letter calls for a halt to all proposals for the use of gene drive technologies "given the obvious dangers of irretrievably releasing genocidal genes into the natural world."

Source: AFP

themuslimchronicle
themuslimchronicle

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

controversial gene drive research sparking ethical debate controversial gene drive research sparking ethical debate

 



Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

GMT 14:15 2017 Thursday ,31 August

Mohamed bin Zayed receives HCT delegation

GMT 07:29 2017 Thursday ,23 February

Kohli issues Starc warning to India's batsmen in Pune

GMT 09:38 2017 Friday ,11 August

At least 36 killed in China bus crash

GMT 06:36 2018 Wednesday ,24 January

World powers step up pressure on Syria, Russia

GMT 21:36 2011 Thursday ,12 May

Euro steadies against dollar

GMT 20:12 2011 Tuesday ,10 May

Qatar exchange up 1.42 %

GMT 08:37 2016 Thursday ,08 September

By alleged toxic bomb attacks in Aleppo

GMT 19:18 2011 Wednesday ,09 February

RiRi - love the way you smell

GMT 22:55 2017 Wednesday ,04 October

Trump says he has 'total confidence' in Tillerson

GMT 10:54 2015 Monday ,23 March

Simple chocolate button egg

GMT 16:37 2015 Saturday ,23 May

Classic lasagne

GMT 19:08 2017 Wednesday ,01 November

Libya coastguard rescues nearly 300 migrants at sea

GMT 04:42 2017 Wednesday ,30 August

Saudi Arabia says ready to welcome

GMT 13:01 2017 Thursday ,30 November

Streaking Cavs survive James' first career ejection
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
 
 Themuslimchronicle Facebook,themuslimchronicle facebook  Themuslimchronicle Twitter,themuslimchronicle twitter Themuslimchronicle Rss,themuslimchronicle rss  Themuslimchronicle Youtube,themuslimchronicle youtube  Themuslimchronicle Youtube,themuslimchronicle youtube

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2023 ©

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2023 ©

muslimchronicle muslimchronicle muslimchronicle muslimchronicle
themuslimchronicle themuslimchronicle themuslimchronicle
themuslimchronicle
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle