the brotherhood’s conflicting statements
Last Updated : GMT 09:40:38
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Last Updated : GMT 09:40:38
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

The Brotherhood’s conflicting statements

Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

the brotherhood’s conflicting statements

Ali Ibrahim

To quote an old Egyptian song, “what beautiful and rational words”. This fully describes the interview published by the New York Times yesterday, with a leading figure in the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, a group that clearly will become the largest bloc in the Egyptian parliament after the January 25th revolution. The interview is interesting and gives a different picture from the typical stereotype derived from the Brotherhood. [Essam] El-Erian spoke as a statesman in this interview, and confirmed that the Brotherhood would respect the Camp David Accords with Israel, because “this is a commitment of the state, not a group or a party, and this we respect”. He hopes that the United States continues to provide its aid to Egypt, under the condition that it doesn’t practice political pressure, reminding his American suitors that they are not the only ones who “come calling”; there are also the Chinese and the Russians. In the interview he also gave an analysis worthy of consideration about the surprisingly strong performance of the Salafis, whom he acknowledged have become a political force, suggesting that the Brotherhood has appealed to the Egyptian middle class whilst the Salafis have turned to the poor. He hopes that Brotherhood can pull the Salafis towards them, rather than the Brotherhood themselves sliding towards greater fanaticism, and if the next government addresses the problem of poverty, it could help to diminish the Salafis’ appeal. El-Erian’s most significant answer was his response to the always awkward Western question about imposing restrictions on personal freedoms or practices, or about the Salafis demanding the ban of bikinis on beaches and prohibiting the sale of alcohol. The response to the question was: “Are you sure that is very important? We are keen to discuss the major issues”, such as the new constitution. This is a political response and the words are reassuring, holding a particular message for the outside world, especially Washington, suggesting that the new government will not turn the tables or make knee-jerk decisions that are harmful to Egyptian interests, so where is the problem with the Muslim Brotherhood? The problem lies in the conflicting statements of Brotherhood leaders, whereby the level of controversy depends on the quality of the statement or who is giving it. In order to prevent its discourse being duplicated, the Muslim Brotherhood issues statements in English, directed towards the Western world primarily, and others in Arabic directed towards the local recipients. An example of this was the recent statement made by the Supreme Guide of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, Mohammed Badi, which brought about controversy that has yet to cease. He suggested that the Arab revolutions have brought the goal of the Muslim Brotherhood - established by its founder, Hassan al-Banna – nearer to a reality, namely to create a worldwide righteous caliphate. This immediately brought to mind the heated rhetoric that was often espoused by the former Supreme Guide, causing controversy on one occasion when he said he would not care if Egypt was ruled by a person from Malaysia, for example. Following their current leader’s remarks about the caliphate, a team of Brotherhood politicians rushed to calm fears and explain that this would not mean a return to the previous form of caliphate, whereby national identity and sovereignty are nullified, but rather something like the European Union (EU) among the Muslim countries. This is something that also needs to be explained, because geography is what unites the EU, while geography does not unite, for example, Indonesia, Pakistan and Egypt. When it comes to the statements of el-Erian and the Supreme Guide, the distance between them – if we analyze their content – is like the distance between Egypt and Indonesia. El-Erian represents the party or the political arm that will have to deal with the political and geographical realities of society and the world, while the Supreme Guide represents an idea, and perhaps an old generation influenced by ideologies. We hope that what el-Erian represents within the Muslim Brotherhood will carry the most weight in the Egyptian political process, if society is to advance and the experience is to succeed.

GMT 09:55 2018 Tuesday ,23 January

Washington chooses Syria as its battleground

GMT 09:52 2018 Tuesday ,23 January

Road ahead full of danger as new front opens in Syria

GMT 09:43 2018 Tuesday ,23 January

Now is the time to revive King’s beautiful struggle

GMT 09:15 2018 Monday ,22 January

US Syria policy leaves many questions unanswered

GMT 09:09 2018 Monday ,22 January

Spend a dollar, save a life

GMT 10:23 2018 Thursday ,18 January

65 Israeli laws that discriminate against non-Jews

GMT 09:52 2018 Thursday ,18 January

The dangerous entanglements of Idlib and Afrin
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

the brotherhood’s conflicting statements the brotherhood’s conflicting statements

 



Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle

GMT 04:05 2016 Saturday ,14 May

EU to provide €55mln for Burundi's people

GMT 08:20 2016 Friday ,22 April

Microsoft profit down 25 percent to $3.8bn

GMT 20:34 2017 Monday ,30 October

Ethiopian 'Red Terror' trial opens in Dutch court

GMT 08:01 2017 Monday ,24 July

A look at major issues Duterte is confronting

GMT 19:41 2017 Wednesday ,23 August

Chad to shutter Qatar embassy, expel diplomats

GMT 01:25 2016 Monday ,26 December

PM congratulates Christians on Christmas
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
Themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle
 
 Themuslimchronicle Facebook,themuslimchronicle facebook  Themuslimchronicle Twitter,themuslimchronicle twitter Themuslimchronicle Rss,themuslimchronicle rss  Themuslimchronicle Youtube,themuslimchronicle youtube  Themuslimchronicle Youtube,themuslimchronicle youtube

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2023 ©

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2023 ©

muslimchronicle muslimchronicle muslimchronicle muslimchronicle
themuslimchronicle themuslimchronicle themuslimchronicle
themuslimchronicle
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle, themuslimchronicle